Almanac of law. Issue 15 (2024), pages 328–339.
DOI: 10.33663/2524-017X-2024-15-328-339
Lvova O. L.
Legal certainty as a value component of quality lawmaking
The article provides a theoretical, practical and legal analysis of the content of legal certainty as a value component of quality lawmaking.
The author focuses on the substantive characterization of the quality of legislation, which is evidenced by clear legal certainty, scientific validity, and comprehensibility of the texts of legal provisions, as well as by the predictable, foreseeable result of their observance and application in the process of law implementation. It is also emphasized that on the way to European integration, Ukraine is implementing European legal norms, in the process of which models of legal relations not always typical for our country and Ukrainian national identity are borrowed, and concepts and terms of not clearly defined content are introduced into the legal field, which prevents their correct understanding and unambiguous interpretation and leads to legal conflicts.
In its decisions, the Constitutional Court of Ukraine has repeatedly emphasized legal certainty as a component of the rule of law, which implies an unambiguous understanding of a legal provision, otherwise it inevitably leads to arbitrariness. The author also emphasizes such characteristics of a legal act as accessibility and predictability, which will enable a person to regulate his or her behavior and foresee the consequences of such behavior.
Given the practical and applied aspect of the issue under study, the author states that there is a globalizing trend towards the replacement of traditional concepts in society and scientific doctrine, for example, with regard to the family, when its natural concept, which exists in Ukraine and is fundamental at the constitutional and international legal levels, is transformed from the «basic natural unit of society» to a «social construct».
It is the inconsistency of the content of legal norms with public expectations and needs, their unclear legal certainty and unpredictability that leads to the adoption of poor quality and ineffective legal acts, which can lead to human rights violations. In particular, in the area of discrimination, there is a competition of human rights, which is caused by artificially created conflicts between fundamental legal acts and newly adopted ones.
As a conclusion, the author proposes to characterize legal certainty as a component of the rule of law principle, which implies an unambiguous understanding and interpretation of the content of a legal provision, its scientific validity, accessibility, and clarity of the purpose pursued by the lawmaker and the intended result.
Key words: rule of law, morality, human rights, lawmaking, law, legal certainty, predictability.
References
- Pro pravotvorchu diialnist: Zakon Ukrainy № 3354-IX vid 24.08.2023. Ofitsiinyi vebportal Verkhovnoi Rady
Ukrainy «Zakonotvorchist». URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/3354-20#Text - Kataloh pravovykh pozytsii Konstytutsiinoho Sudu (za rishenniamy, vysnovkamy). Verkhovenstvo prava.
Konstytutsiinyi Sud Ukrainy: Ofiinyi vebsait. URL: https://ccu.gov.ua/storinka-knygy/34-verhovenstvo-prava - Tsuvina T. A. Pryntsyp verkhovenstva prava u praktytsi Yevropeiskoho sudu z prav liudyny. Chasopys
Kyivskoho universytetu prava. 2019/4. S. 373–379. S. 374. - Pashuk T. I. Peredbachuvanist normatyvnykh pidstav dystsyplinarnoi vidpovidalnosti suddiv:
zahalnoteoretychnyi aspekt. Naukovi zapysky NaUKMA. Yurydychni nauky. 2019. Tom 3. S. 100–108. - Kravets O. Zastosuvannia yurydychnoi vyznachenosti yak elementa verkhovenstva prava: praktychni porady
suddi. PravoUA. Iurydychna praktyka. 07.12.2021. URL: https://pravo.ua/zastosuvannia-iurydychnoivyznachenosti-iak-elementu-verkhovenstva-prava-praktychni-porady-suddi/ - Bernaziuk Yan. Katehoriia «iakist zakonu» yak skladova pryntsypu verkhovenstva prava ta harantiia
zastosuvannia sudom naibilsh spryiatlyvoho dlia osoby tlumachennia zakonu. Sudebno-yurydycheskaia hazeta.
21.10.2020. URL: https://supreme.court.gov.ua/supreme/pres-centr/zmi/1011199 - Iakist. Slovnyk ukrainskoi movy. URL: https://slovnyk.ua/index.php?swrd=%D1%8F%D0%BA%D1%96%D1
%81%D1%82%D1%8C - Efektyvnyi. Slovnyk ukrainskoi movy. URL: https://slovnyk.ua/index.php?swrd=%D0%B5%D1%84%D0%B
5%D0%BA%D1%82%D0%B8%D0%B2%D0%BD%D0%B8%D0%B9 - Demchenko A. O., Momot O. I. Pro sutnist poniat «efektyvnist» ta «rezultatyvnist» v ekonomitsi. Ekonomichnyi
visnyk Donbasu. 2013. № 3 (33). S. 207–210. - Shutak I. D. Yurydychna tekhnika: kurs lektsii. Ivano-Frankivsk: Laboratoriia akademichnykh doslidzhen
pravovoho rehuliuvannia ta yurydychnoi tekhniky. Drohobych: Kolo, 2015. 228 s. - Pro media: Zakon Ukrainy № 2849-IX. Iz zminamy, vnesenymy zghidno iz Zakonamy № 2710-IX vid
03.11.2022, № 3136-IX vid 30.05.2023. Ofitsiinyi vebportal Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy «Zakonotvorchist».
URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/rada/show/2849-IX#Text - Lvova O. L. Mova vorozhnechi. Pravova derzhava. Vyp. 29. Kyiv: In-t derzhavy i prava im. V. M. Koretskoho
NAN Ukrainy, 2018. S. 63–71. - Rekomendatsiia Rady Yevropy № 97 (20) «Pro naklepnytski vyslovliuvannia», ukhvalena Komitetom ministriv
30 zhovtnia 1997 r. Standarty Rady Yevropy u sferi media. Zakonodavchyi biuleten. Kyiv: IREX U-Media,
2005. S. 47–49. URL: http://www.archives.gov.ua/International/R_E_final.pdf - Pershyi v Ukraini prypys za «pidburiuvannia do dyskryminatsii za oznakamy SOHI» otrymav sait vsirazom.ua.
Yaki prychyny i shcho dali? Sait Hromadianskoho rukhu «Vsi razom!». 13.03.2024. URL: https://vsirazom.ua/
news/pershyj-v-ukrayini-prypys-za-pidburyuvannya-do-dyskryminacziyi-za-oznakamy-sogi-otrymav-sajtivsirazom-ua-yaki-prychyny-i-shho-dali. - Rishennia Natsionalnoi rady Ukrainy z pytan telebachennia i radiomovlennia № 624 vid 07.03.2024 «Pro
vynesennia prypysu subiektu v sferi onlain-media HO «Hromadianskyi rukh «Vsi razom!». Vebportal
Natsionalnoi rady telebachennia i radiomovlennia. URL: https://webportal.nrada.gov.ua/wp-content/
uploads/2024/03/R-2024-00624.pdf - Rishennia Natsrady proty Rukhu «Vsi razom!» superechyt zakonu, ye dyskryminatsiinym i vzhe oskarzhene
u sudi. 14.03.2024. Sait Hromadianskoho rukhu «Vsi razom!». URL: https://vsirazom.ua/news/oficzijnorishennya-naczrady-proty-ruhu-vsi-razom-superechyt-zakonu-ye-dyskryminaczijnym-i-vzhe-oskarzhene-usudi - Proekt zakonu pro instytut reiestrovanykh partnerstv № 9103 vid 13.03.2023. Ofitsiinyi vebportal Verkhovnoi
Rady Ukrainy «Zakonotvorchist». URL: https://itd.rada.gov.ua/billInfo/Bills/Card/41497 - Mokhniuk R. Shliub chy odnostatevi partnerstva: novyi zakon. Sait «HO «Vsi razom». Kabinet ekspertiv.
05.04.2023. URL: https://vsirazom.ua/cabinet/kardinalno-protilezhni-rechi-shlyub-ta-partnerstvo/ - Rishennia Konstytutsiinoho Sudu Ukrainy № 15-rp/2004 vid 2 lystopada 2004 roku u spravi za konstytutsiinym
podanniam Verkhovnoho Sudu Ukrainy shchodo vidpovidnosti Konstytutsii Ukrainy (konstytutsiinosti)
polozhen statti 69 Kryminalnoho kodeksu Ukrainy sprava pro pryznachennia sudom bilsh miakoho pokarannia).
Ofitsiinyi vebportal Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy «Zakonotvorchist». URL: http://zakon3.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/
v015p710-04 - Naukovo-pravova ekspertyza № 01-9/1-232 vid 25.12.2023 / Naukovo-doslidnyi instytut pryvatnoho prava i
pidpryiemnytstva imeni akademika F. H. Burchaka. URL: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1WBlOWLPCWkjP
1UwGyT0FYVWNDpIpQCpa/view (data zvernennia: 02.04.2024). - Medvedieva M. O. Pravovi aspekty zaborony dyskryminatsii za oznakoiu SOHI v konteksti Yevrointehratsii
Ukrainy. Yurydychnyi naukovyi elektronnyi zhurnal. № 1/2024. S. 696–701. URL: http://www.lsej.org.
ua/1_2024/169.pdf - Lvova O. L. Suchasni vyklyky ta zahrozy instytutu simi v Ukraini. Mat-ly Mizhnarodnoho Forumu «Vzaiemodiia
politykiv i hromadskosti u prosuvanni khrystyianskykh tsinnostei na mizhnarodnii areni» (2–3 chervnia 2016 r.).
Kyiv, 2016. S. 24–27. - Konstytutsiia Lytovskoi respubliky. URL: https://legalns.com/download/books/cons/lithuania.pdf
- Zakonoproekt pro dopovnennia statti 2.23(1) Tsyvilnoho kodeksu Lytvy. Sait Seimu Lytovskoi Respubliky.
URL: https://e-seimas.lrs.lt/portal/legalAct/lt/TAP/0b7ebb00d79011ecb1b39d276e924a5d - Konventsiia pro zakhyst prav liudyny i osnovopolozhnykh svobod (z protokolamy) (Ievropeiska konventsiia
z prav liudyny). Konventsiiu ratyfikovano Zakonom № 475/97-VR vid 17.07.1997. Ofitsiinyi vebportal
Verkhovnoi Rady Ukrainy «Zakonotvorchist». URL: https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/995_004#Text - Lvova O. L. Kryterii moralnosti i pryrodnosti u suchasnomu pravotvorenni. Almanakh prava. Pravovyi
monitorynh i pravova ekspertyza: pytannia teorii ta praktyky. 2019. Vyp. 10. S. 167–176.
Olena Leonidivna Lvova,
Senior Researcher, Department of Theory of State and Law, Institute of State and Law named after V. M. Koretsky, NAS of Ukraine,
Candidate of Law,
Senior Researcher
ORCID: 0000-0003-2985-9671